Skip to content

Collie ESG

Advancing best practice in ESG investing
  • Home

Response to the DOL’s proposed rule on prudence and loyalty in selecting plan investments and exercising shareholder rights

  • bobcollie
  • December 10, 2021
  • Regulation
  • collieesg, ESG policy, externalities, TCFD

This post links to comments submitted to the US Department of Labor regarding their proposed rule on prudence and loyalty in selecting plan investments and exercising shareholder rights

Carbon pricing is a pro-market move. If you believe in markets, you should be fighting for it.

  • bobcollie
  • November 11, 2021
  • Regulation
  • carbon pricing, carbon tax, collieesg, esg, externalities

A belief in markets should not be dogmatic like a belief in Santa Claus; it should be based on a clear understanding of the necessary conditions for markets to serve the overall good, and a clear understanding of what can cause them to fail.

Six questions to ask about your ESG policy

  • bobcollie
  • October 20, 2021
  • Investment policy
  • esg, ESG policy, esginvesting, five tests, investment impact, six tests

“Hold on a moment”, you may be thinking. “Didn’t you just write a post about the five tests of an ESG policy?”
Well, yes I did. But sometimes we need to revisit things. And it turns out there are not just five tests, but six.

The UK pension community’s big roll out of climate scenario analysis: what will it achieve?

  • bobcollie
  • September 30, 2021
  • Commentary, Regulation
  • climate scenario analysis, ESG policy, TCFD

Scenario analysis is a valuable risk tool, but unfamiliar to many investors. It’s about the particular, not the general; qualitative as well as quantitative; and it’s about the journey not the destination.

The Financial Times says ESG investing is dangerous. I disagree.

  • bobcollie
  • August 24, 2021
  • Commentary, Regulation
  • collieesg, esginvesting, esgisdangerous, greenwashing

It is wrong to attack ESG as a smokescreen, distracting from effective policy action. Public policy is the highest priority, but it alone will not be enough. We need investor action too. Don’t write off every investment manager as irredeemably part of the problem.

What can’t be measured well can still be managed. On climate impact, it needs to be.

  • bobcollie
  • July 28, 2021
  • Commentary, Regulation
  • esg, esg measurement, esginvesting, TCFD

Better measurement of ESG factors is important. But it’s not enough. We can’t afford to wait for perfect measurement before taking other action.

Best practice in ESG investing: not just the sum of the parts

  • bobcollie
  • June 5, 2021
  • Commentary
  • esgbestpractice, esginvesting

ESG becoming mainstream could just mean splicing together the standard investment tradition with social responsibility, hoping not to do too much damage to the integrity of either in the process. Best practice, though, is more than that; it is a synthesis.

ESG investing: how different is the US?

  • bobcollie
  • April 14, 2021
  • Commentary, Market overview
  • ESG the US is different, esginvesting

The US is different when it comes to ESG investing. The key to understanding that difference may lie in the unspoken context, in the things that are taken for granted.

Marking one hundred years of ignoring Frank Knight’s point about risk and uncertainty

  • bobcollie
  • March 23, 2021
  • Commentary, Market overview
  • ESG risk, ESG uncertainty, Frank Knight, Knightian uncertainty, risk, uncertainty

It is 100 years since Frank Knight’s Risk, Uncertainty and Profit first highlighted that some risks are quantifiable and others are not. But Knight’s main conclusion is widely, and wrongly, ignored.

It’s handy to express natural and human capital in financial terms – here are four reasons that’s tough to do

  • bobcollie
  • February 25, 2021
  • Commentary
  • esginvesting, externalities, natural capital, value of nature

It’s handy, and often necessary, to look at ESG factors through a financial lens. But it only captures part of the picture.

  • «
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • »

Recent commentary

  • To understand the development of ESG investing, think in terms of co-evolution rather than evolution
  • A brief history of how ESG forced its way into the investment mainstream, and what happens next
  • The best path for today’s teenagers/students to make a difference on the environment
  • ESG calls for a rethink of how you see the world: seven ways investment organizations may need to update their maps
  • Biodiversity is becoming an investment issue

© 2025 · Collie ESG · Powered By Greenlet